top of page

Early retirement life: we chose to be worse off!

Why would anyone choose to be worse off?

In our case, we chose to live in France. Now, when you hear people talking about France, it might be about the wine, the food, the bureaucracy - they even invented the word! But what you don't hear anyone say is that France is a low tax country...because it most certainly is not!


Living in France increases our annual tax bill by £3,200/$4,000/€3,700. That's something to think about. And from 2025, that will increase to £11,700/$14,400/€13,600 per year. Wowsers, now that's a BIG number, and one we can avoid simply by living somewhere else.


We must be odd people - choosing to be worse off seems a strange thing...


Surely not many people choose to be worse off!

But that's not true. In fact, choosing to be worse off is probably the norm rather than the exception. The question is whether it's a conscious choice.


In the early days of my early retirement, I took some time to look at my costs. I asked myself:


1. Is this item of expenditure good value for money?
2. Can I get the same thing for less money?

The result of this exercise was that I:


  1. Changed our TV and mobile phone packages

  2. Switched to a lower cost supermarket

  3. Started using a shopping list

  4. Took time to shop around

  5. Exchanged time for money e.g. taking an indirect rather than a direct flight

  6. Changed our utility provider

  7. Didn't accept the first quote

  8. Used a gift list

  9. Paused before buying

In my post about it, I calculated that making these changes saved us £4,471/$6,305/€5,200 a year. Importantly, these changes didn't impact our quality of life.


Around the same time, we also went from being a two car family to a one car family as well as downsizing our accommodation when our kids left for university - the saving from these were even bigger.


Before making these changes, I was effectively choosing to be worse off. Whether it was because of laziness, apathy, or simply not realising how much could be saved - it was costing us a lot! At least better late than never, we made the changes - we stopped choosing to be worse off.


That was over four years ago, a different life, when we lived in Dubai. It's probably past time for another review - choosing not to be worse off is not a set and forget thing.


However, I'm not arguing that we must always spend the least amount of money possible. Life is about finding a balance - we work hard for our money, and there's nothing wrong with spending some of it on the things that make us happy. We've chosen to spend an extra £3,200/$4,000/€3,700 each year in tax to live in France, and that's worth it to me. Yes, we are financially worse off, but I'm enjoying the life that flows from this decision. As we get closer to 2025, I'll have to think about it some more, am I willing to spend an extra £11,700/$14,400/€13,600 on tax for this life? That's going to be a tough decision.


One of my pet hates is the concept of keeping up with the Joneses. Society, with plenty of help from the marketing people, is very adept at encouraging us to do this. I know that I'm not immune from it, but I find it the most annoying way that we choose to be worse off.


At the same time, we shouldn't think that we need to be frugalists either. Living at a low cost can be something of a FIRE mantra. Spend less > saving more = get to FIRE more quickly. Spend less > need a smaller retirement investment pot = get to FIRE more quickly. These things are true, but are best done with some balance. I'm a big fan of financial independence (and retiring early if that's your thing), but it's important to enjoy the journey to FIRE too.


So choosing to be worse off is a thing - in fact, I suspect a very common thing, and we're far from unique in doing it. If it's done consciously, for good reason, then choosing to be worse off can be good. But if it's done unknowingly, through laziness, apathy, or to keep up with the Joneses, hmm, then there is probably some work to be done.

6 comments

Recent Posts

See All

6 Comments


Joe Lie
Joe Lie
Aug 19, 2022

your post gives information about France. We decided to settle in France. Currently, when you hear people discussing France, they may be referring to the cuisine, wine, or even the bureaucracy (they even created the word)! However, you never hear anybody claim that France has low taxes, as this is absolutely untrue. Most of people spend vacation in this country.If you are a student and need an assignment then I recommend that you should contact doctoral thesis service.Which will solve your any problems.

Like
Replying to

Thanks for the comment, Joe, although I'm not sure how the doctoral thesis service will solve my problems...in fact, I'm not even sure what problems need to be solved!🤔

Like

It's all a matter of perspective I guess. I went to a dinner to say goodbye to some work friends recently. We weren't able to get together till now thanks to covid. They all were all interested in what I was doing and said that they couldn't quit because they were making so much money. So by their standard I made myself worse off by quitting before I had to. By mine, I would have wasted some active years sitting at a desk for money I didn't need anyway. Like you, I choose to have less money and enjoy my life more!

Like
Replying to

I'm not saying this applies to your friends/former colleagues, but it is interesting that people quite likely continue to do something they'd rather not do, just to earn more money than they actually need. I think we're in the minority, but our choice seems to make so much sense (at least to us!)

Like

As you've rightly mentioned, in life time, quality (sometimes perceived) and money all go hand in hand. If you want to save time you fly direct, or outsource your cleaning etc. You associate a value (I.e the cost) with saving time, or living in a certain area etc.


Anyhoo, I've often found I ha e the power to make choices based on what I perceive to be valuable to me at that point in time. I spend more time and get more enjoyment with my family at home so choose to live somewhere nicer but drive a beat up old car as it doesn't excite me as much. The list goes on etc.


The joy (and value) you get everyday…

Like
Replying to

I completely agree - we make choices with regard to what's important to us and how much value we attach to things. And we're all different, so what you think of as good value may be different to what I think, but we can both be correct even with different opinions. What I think is interesting, is how often (and how much) we spend without carrying out a value sense check. I know that at one time, I had so many cable TV channels for which I paid a high monthly fee, and it was only when I took a moment to think about it that I realised I didn't watch most of them. That wasn't good value, and when I…

Like
bottom of page